Digital Independence Day: A Call to Reclaim Our Digital Autonomy
Reflections from the Science in the City Festival Malta — September 17, 2025
Why Digital Autonomy Matters
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: when digital systems fail, society fails.
Consider these recent examples:
- Hospital ransomware attacks where patients died during transfers because electronic records were encrypted by attackers
- Cambridge Analytica harvesting 87 million Facebook profiles for election manipulation
- Meta deliberately testing harmful algorithms on adolescents, knowing Instagram increased teen depression
- Israel’s Operation Grim Beeper, where consumer pagers were remotely weaponized, killing 12 people
- Oracle’s BlueKai profiling 5 billion people worldwide without consent, then selling that data to debt collectors and insurance companies
These aren’t isolated incidents. They’re symptoms of a systemic problem: we’ve handed control of our critical infrastructure—healthcare, logistics, finance, democracy, education—to entities whose interests fundamentally conflict with ours.
Floridi’s thesis in The Fourth Revolution (2014) makes this clear: we now inhabit a world where information systems are society. Control over those systems equals control over society itself.
The Opposition Alliance
Who benefits from our digital dependence?
Surveillance capitalism extracts behavioral data at unprecedented scale, manipulates user behavior through algorithmic control, and creates dependencies to maintain market dominance. Google, Apple, Facebook, Amazon, Microsoft—combined market cap over $10 trillion—have built their empires on this model.
Authoritarian states monitor populations, suppress dissent through platform manipulation, and weaponize civilian technology. China’s social credit system surveils 1.4 billion people. NSA’s PRISM collected data from major US tech companies for years. Pegasus spyware has been sold to 40+ governments to spy on journalists, activists, and politicians.
The alliance between surveillance capitalism and state control isn’t accidental. It’s symbiotic.
Fighting Back: FOSS as Democratic Infrastructure
But here’s the liberating reality: alternatives exist, and they work.
Governments are already proving this:
- 🇩🇪 Schleswig-Holstein: Migrating 30,000 PCs to Linux and LibreOffice, ending Microsoft dependency
- 🇫🇷 Lyon: 17,000 government computers moved to Ubuntu, saving €2M annually
- 🇪🇸 Extremadura: 200,000 students educated on Linux-based systems
- 🇧🇷 Brazil: Constitutional requirement for open standards in government systems
These aren’t small pilot projects. They’re large-scale migrations that demonstrate digital sovereignty is achievable.
The difference between proprietary software and Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) isn’t just technical—it’s political:
- Proprietary software: Black box code, vendor control, surveillance capabilities built-in
- “Open Source” (Silicon Valley style): Source visible but corporate-controlled, “open washing” marketing
- FOSS: Community governance, transparent code, privacy by default, no surveillance by design
Your Liberation Toolkit
During the Malta workshop, we explored practical alternatives. Here’s a snapshot:
Communication:
- WhatsApp → Signal (end-to-end encrypted, normie-friendly)
- Twitter/X → Mastodon (decentralized, choose your instance)
- Discord → Element/Matrix (self-hostable, federated)
Productivity:
- Microsoft Office → LibreOffice (full compatibility, European government-backed)
- Notion → Logseq (local-first knowledge graphs)
- Slack → Mattermost (self-hosted team communication)
Infrastructure:
- Google Drive → Nextcloud (complete cloud replacement)
- Android (Google) → GrapheneOS or LineageOS (privacy-hardened mobile OS)
- Windows/macOS → GNU/Linux (hundreds of distributions, full control)
Web browsing:
- Chrome → LibreWolf (Firefox without telemetry, hardened by default)
- Add uBlock Origin and Privacy Badger for tracker blocking
The Trade-offs (Because Everything Has a Price)
I won’t lie to you: FOSS isn’t always smooth sailing.
- Self-responsibility: No corporate helpdesk to call when things break
- Modular solutions: Unix philosophy of “do one thing well” means more tools to learn
- Social isolation: Harder to organize when everyone else uses WhatsApp/Instagram
- Binary limitations: Proprietary formats like
.docxaren’t easily human-readable (though they’re actually just ZIP archives containing XML)
But here’s the counterpoint: proprietary software has worse trade-offs—you just don’t see them. Surveillance, vendor lock-in, algorithmic manipulation, and the inability to audit what’s running on your own device. Those are the hidden costs.
Your Roadmap to Digital Independence
I structured the workshop around a Kyū ranking system (borrowed from Japanese martial arts), indicating progressive mastery:
1. Kyū (yellow belt 🟡):
Start with daily-use software—lowest friction changes:
- Communication tools (Signal, Element)
- Web browser (LibreWolf with uBlock Origin)
- Office suite (LibreOffice)
2. Kyū (orange belt 🟠):
Deeper system changes requiring some technical comfort:
- Operating system migration (GNU/Linux)
- FOSS app stores (F-Droid for Android)
- Publishing systems (Marp for presentations, Pandoc for documents)
3. Kyū (green belt 🟢):
Infrastructure independence—highest technical requirements:
- Cloud storage (Nextcloud, Syncthing)
- Self-hosting (Coop Cloud, Abra for containerized apps)
Don’t skip ahead. Each level builds on the previous. Start where you are.
Why This Matters: Learned Helplessness vs. Digital Sovereignty
One of the most insidious aspects of proprietary technology is the learned helplessness it creates. When you can’t choose your phone’s default browser, can’t audit the code running on your laptop, can’t export your data from a platform—you internalize the belief that you need these corporations.
But that’s a lie.
The workshop participants—many with zero technical background—successfully installed LibreOffice, explored GNU/Linux distributions via live USB drives, and ran their first terminal commands (pwd, ls, cd). They discovered something crucial: they could do this.
Digital sovereignty isn’t about becoming a software engineer. It’s about refusing the false binary of “accept surveillance or go offline.” There’s a third path: build and use democratic technology.
Closing Thoughts
In Floridi’s infosphere, our digital choices are political choices.
When Oracle CEO Larry Ellison brags about profiling 5 billion people without consent, that’s not just a business model—it’s a power structure.
When governments migrate to FOSS, they’re not just saving money—they’re asserting democratic control over their infrastructure.
When you switch from WhatsApp to Signal, you’re not just changing apps—you’re refusing to be a product.
Digital independence is a democratic necessity. Not because technology is inherently liberating, but because who controls it determines who controls society.
Take Action
Workshop materials and slides:
https://git.dailysh.it/nextlevelshit/malta-slides
FOSS alternative directory:
https://www.opensourcealternative.to/
OSS Malta community:
https://ossmalta.eu/
This presentation is licensed under Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0). Share it, adapt it, use it to build your own workshops. Just keep it free.
References:
- Floridi, L. (2014). The Fourth Revolution: How the infosphere is reshaping human reality. Oxford University Press.
- Full reference list available in the slide deck at https://git.dailysh.it/nextlevelshit/malta-slides